Dear Nonconathon Author '24

[robberbaroness]

Thank you so much for offering one of my requests! I’m excited for porn, melodrama, and especially pornographic melodrama! As always, I very much opt in to treats.



General likes: Bondage, love interest forced to watch, heavy melodrama, 'I have you now my pretty' scenarios', abduction and captivity, forced kissing, manhandling, obsessive villains, hurt/comfort, dialogue-heavy foreplay, possessiveness, impact play, defiant victims, threats, praise, bodice rippers, revenge tragedies, gothic horror, fairy tales.

General dislikes: Comeplay, golden showers or scat, ugly aggressors, victims under 16, victim death, victim blaming, victims being called ugly, daddy kink, mindbreak, race-based humiliation, generative AI stuff.

Red Eye
Jackson Rippner noncons Lisa Reisert

Captivity
Bondage
Intimacy - Falsely Gentle Threatening Touches
Intimacy - Forced Kissing
Obsession - Yandere
Manhandling - Shoved and Dragged
Oral - Rapist finger fucks victim's mouth
Praise - Condescending Praise
Resistance - Defiant Victim

This was THE movie for awful villain/heroine ships! Sexual tension turns dangerous, and danger turns into sexual tension. I was extremely happy when he said “I may have to steal you!” You could follow up on that, with him taking Lisa away as a prisoner, or set things during the events of the movie (the airplane bathroom scene would make sense, or when he follows her home.) My DNW for this movie is dwelling on the fate of the politician and his family- even if this is a version where Jackson wins, I don’t need the details. Or maybe Lisa still saves them, but Jackson decides to keep her rather than kill her for it? Or could she make some kind of bargain where she offers herself to her infatuated foe in exchange for their or her father’s life? The story can end with either Jackson or Lisa winning, or ambiguously, I’m fine with whatever.

Horrible Histories
Dick Turpin noncons Original Female Characters

Bondage
Bondage - Bound and Gagged
Captivity - Molested While Used as Human Shield
Aftermath - Friends/Family/Team's Reaction
Aftermath - Rapist Falls in Love with Former Victim
Captivity - Kidnapping/Imprisonment
Intimacy - Falsely Gentle Threatening Touches
Intimacy - Forced Kissing
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time
Guns - Raped at Gunpoint
Manhandling - Shoved and Dragged
Manhandling - Bodice Ripper Style Ravishment
Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty
Position - Carried Over the Shoulder
Praise - Condescending Praise

What can I say, I’m a sucker for a man in period garb and eyeliner talking about how he has a ruthless killer’s heart! What might he do with a lady (or ladies) whose carriage he robbed? Simple ravishment? Outright abduction? Might his exploits be covered in an incredibly salacious manner by a less than reliable writer getting paid by the word? And just how handy with a knife is he? As this is from a comedy show, it’s fine to temper his danger with a little bit of incompetence, or you can play it totally straight.

Outlander Series
Jonathan “Black Jack” Randall noncons Clair Beauchamp

Captivity
Captivity - Bathe Them and Bring Them To Me
Aftermath - Rescue
Bondage
Obsession
Love Interest Forced to Watch
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Manhandling - Shoved and Dragged
Manhandling - Bodice Ripper Style Ravishment
Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty
Position - Carried Over the Shoulder

I’ve only read the first book, but I was extremely intrigued by this villain who so closely resembled Claire’s lost love even as he was being incredibly cruel- but for better or for worse, it didn’t end up playing with that much. What if it had? What if Jack, already such a psychologically fucked-up man, found that his obsession with Jamie had now grown into an obsession with his wife as well? What if the way she acted so familiar towards him and yet also so afraid proved infuriatingly seductive? This can happen any time in the first book, in addition to or instead of what he does to Jamie, instead of or a continuation of his attack on her when she’s trying to reach the stones, etc. I don’t want him to just be going after her to upset or as a proxy for Jamie, but feel free to explore the psychological twistiness or all this. I just want to see this nasty man be nasty to our heroine!

Dungeons & Dragons
Strahd von Zarovich noncons Tatyana Federovna

Bad End - Kept in Harem
Captivity
Bondage
Captivity - Abduction as Seduction
Obsession - Yandere
Love Interest Forced to Watch
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Praise - Condescending Praise
Position - Carried Over the Shoulder
Captivity - Repeated Rapes in Comfortable Captive Scenario

God/Pelor bless the newest Ravenloft manual for giving us a whole chart to roll on to find out what Tatyana thinks of her supernatural stalker! This could be the original Tatyana, set upon by her husband’s brother at his castle while a massacre takes place downstairs; it could also be an incarnation who is an adventurer (PC class and race of your choice!) already planning to fight him when he decided she was his true love! As a note, while I’m big on Ravenloft throughout the editions and novels, I haven’t been following general 5E metaplot very closely; I’ll enjoy references but won’t be a stickler for lore.

Lost Boys
David noncons Star

Captivity
Bondage
Bad End - Kept as Sex Slaves
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time
Manhandling - Shoved and Dragged
Degradation - Victim Treated as Property
Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty
Oral - Rapist finger fucks victim's mouth
Praise - Condescending Praise

I read Lost in the Shadows, the book about the making of the Lost Boys, and Joel Schumacher talked about how David treated Star like property, which definitely made me want to request this! I’d love to see the lurid circumstances behind Star coming to live with David and his gang. It could have been something like what happened to Michael, where she was enticed into the cave and tricked into tricking David’s blood while the boys chanted her name, followed by sex she intitially agreed to which suddenly took a turn for the horrific when she realized she wasn’t going to be allowed to leave. She could have been outright kidnapped, a treat for the evening whom David decided he enjoyed enough to keep around. I love David’s mixture of seductive temptation and brash punk machismo, and I’d love to see him pushing around and taking possession of Star. The bad-trip cave scene after the blood drinking in the movie gives a great feeling of hallucinogenic eroticism, and I would love if you could capture some of that.

DCU
Lex Luthor noncons Lois Lane

Captivity
Aftermath - Rescue
Bondage
Clothing - Forced to Wear Revealing Clothing
Captivity - Repeated Rapes in Comfortable Captive Scenario
Attitude - Dispassionate Rapist
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Manhandling - Shoved and Dragged
Resistance - Defiant Victim
Resistance - Victim Fights Back
Oral - Rapist finger fucks victim's mouth
Praise - Condescending Praise

Clancy Brown’s voice in the DCAU got me thinking about Lex Luthor in a whole new light, and whenever he’s interested in Lois in the comics makes me happy! So let’s expand upon that. What happens after the supervillain gets his hands on the damsel in distress? This could take place anywhere in the main comics timeline, or elsewhere in the multiverse- I greatly enjoyed him trying to exercise droit du seignor as her liege lord in the Elseworlds story Kal. I love Lois’s resilience no matter the era, and I am extremely into Clark’s chivalric devotion to her if you want to throw that in as a hurt/comfort bonus.

Protomen
Dr. Wiley noncons Emily Stanton

Captivity
Bondage
Clothing - Forced to Wear Revealing Clothing
Attitude - Dispassionate Rapist
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty

Act II: Father of Death was released more than ten years ago, and I’ve been thinking about Wiley creeping on Emily ever since! Could something have happened instead of him killing her when she refused to go away with him? Might he have simply taken her away with him anyway? What would it be like to be a captive cyborg bride? How would this affect the rest of the story? Does Light know, or what happens when he finds out? And just how could cybernetics be used for pornographic purposes?

Ancient Greek Religion and Lore
Paris noncons Helen

Captivity
Aftermath - Rescue
Bondage
Obsession
Magical Restraints
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty
Position - Carried Over the Shoulder

The first version of this story I ever read had Paris outright abducting Helen (alongside a picture of him grabbing her that mysteriously intrigued me!) so that’s always stuck with me. I think it would have been a very typically dickish godly move on Aphrodite’s part to set this up- “I said I would give her to you, I never said she would go willingly…” Paris may be handsome and noble but he’s also incredibly entitled, so who cares if Helen said no if she counts as his prize? Poor Helen probably feels some kind of attraction for him, but that doesn’t mean she wanted to leave her husband and start a war- but now a whole city (except maybe Hector) is complicit in keeping her captive because it’s become a matter of civic honor!

BBC Robin Hood
Guy of Gisborne noncons Marian of Knighton

Obsession - Yandere
Obsession - I Love You Too Much to Ever Let You Go
Bondage
Aftermath - Rapist Feels Guilty
Forced to Watch - Victim Raped in Front of Loved One(s)
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Manhandling - Shoved and Dragged
Position - Carried Over the Shoulder
Marriage - Forced Consummation

I’m stunned at how hard it is to find maledom with Guy on AO3, given that he was everyone’s bad boy crush back in the day! Anyway, this scenario could make all that predatory back-and-forth with Marian finally go all the way, with a consummate forced marriage or just Guy pushing his affections on her. Marian is always a fighter and that would probably hold true here as well. Guy is probably not a sadist, but perhaps a little bit of brutality is what he needs for his purposes. Robin can be alluded to, forced to watch (which is fun but don’t have him victim-blame Marian!) or barely mentioned. I’m fine with Marian escaping or not at the end, and with Guy feeling guilty or fully justified.

Original M/F

Captivity
Aftermath - Rescue
Bondage
Clothing - Forced to Wear Revealing Clothing
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time
Bad End - Kept as Sex Slaves
Forced to Watch - Victim Raped in Front of Loved One(s)
Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped
Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty
Obsession - I Love You Too Much to Ever Let You Go
Praise - Condescending Praise
Position - Carried Over the Shoulder

Mob boss noncons female private detective

She can’t be allowed to escape, but it seems a shame to kill her.

Mob boss noncons wife of man who owes him money

He has to take some kind of payment, after all.

1950s greaser noncons shy nerdy girl

Beware boys who wear leather and read comic books!

Evil knight noncons captive maiden

What’s a damsel in distress without someone to distress her?

Brooding lord of the manor noncons plucky gothic heroine

They weren’t kidding when they said he was dangerous.

Mad scientist’s evil alter ego noncons his fiance

It’s not really his fault- or is it?

Supehero’s evil multiverse duplicate noncons his love interest

No matter the universe, he thinks, she belongs to him.

Victorian Slave Trader noncons Upper Class Woman He Is Selling

Those stories about how if you went down the wrong alley you’d get sold over seas can’t be true, right?

Pirate Captain noncons Aristocratic Prisoner

Is she bound for auction, or for his personal keeping?

Regency Highwayman noncons Aristocratic Traveller

Everything I said about Horrible Histories also goes for a highwayman of your creation!