Dear Nonconathon '22 Author...

[robberbaroness]

 

It’s that exciting time of year again! Thank you so much for choosing one of my fandoms!

General likes: Bondage, love interest forced to watch, heavy melodrama, 'I have you now my pretty' scenarios', abduction and captivity, forced kissing, manhandling, obsessive villains, hurt/comfort, dialogue-heavy foreplay, anal and vaginal fingering, posessiveness, impact play, defiant victims, threats, praise, bodice rippers, revenge tragedies, gothic horror, fairy tales.

General dislikes: Comeplay, golden showers or scat, ugly aggressors, victims under 16, victim death, victim blaming, daddy kink, mindbreak.

Robin Hood (BBC 2006)

Guy of Gisborne noncons Marian of Knighton (BBC Robin Hood)

• Aftermath - Rapist Feels Guilty 

• Attitude - Rapist Feels Guilty But Rapes Anyway 

• Bondage 

• Captivity 

• Captivity - Kidnapping/Imprisonment 

• Imprisonment - Locked in a Tower 

• Intimacy - Falsely Gentle Threatening Touches 

• Intimacy - Forced Kissing 

• Intimacy - Forced to dance with rapist 

• Intimacy - Victim Treated Like Lover 

• Love Interest Forced to Watch 

• Manhandling 

• Manhandling - Bodice Ripper Style Ravishment 

• Obsession - I Love You Too Much To Ever Let You Go 

• Obsession - Rapist In Love With Victim 

• Resistance - Defiant Victim 

• Resistance - Victim Fights Back 

• Resistance - Victim Mocks Rapist(s) 

• Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped

I’m stunned at how hard it is to find maledom with Guy on AO3, given that he was everyone’s bad boy crush back in the day! Anyway, this scenario could make all that predatory back-and-forth with Marian finally go all the way, with a consummate forced marriage or just Guy pushing his affections on her. Marian is always a fighter and that would probably hold true here as well. Guy is probably not a sadist, but perhaps a little bit of brutality is what he needs for his purposes. Robin can be alluded to, forced to watch (which is fun but don’t have him victim-blame Marian!) or barely mentioned. I’m fine with Marian escaping or not at the end, and  with Guy feeling guilty or fully justified.

Midsommar (2019)

Ingemar noncons Connie (Midsommar)

• Arousal - Aroused Victim 

• Attitude - Gentle Rapist 

• Bargaining - Victim Offers/Sacrifices Self to Protect Others 

• Bondage 

• Captivity 

• Intimacy - Falsely Gentle Threatening Touches 

• Intimacy - Forced Kissing 

• Intimacy - Rapist Plays with Victim’s Hair 

• Intimacy - Victim Treated Like Lover 

• Marriage - Marital/Spousal Rape 

• Motive - Rape to Claim Ownership of Victim 

• Obsession - Yandere 

• Praise - Condescending Praise 

• Punishment - For Being in a Consensual Relationship 

• Scenario - Gentle Rape 

• Substances - Victim is Drugged

I really thought this was where the movie was going! Obviously not, but I think adding more “new blood” in the form of a captive bride would have been a creepy but intriguing reason he invited his ex-girlfriend to the farm. Connie isn’t in quite as vulnerable a psychological state as Danni, but Ingemar might still believe she’ll ultimately come around. The Harga’s passive-aggressive seduction, drugging and brainwashing could come into play here, along with more aggressive captivity. I’d rather you not emphasize the implied racism of the cult, though that’s probably obvious from the pairing!

Outlander Series - Diana Gabaldon

Black Jack Randall noncons Claire Fraiser (Outlander - Gabaldon)

• Aftermath - Loved One Comforts Victim 

• Begging 

• Bondage - Ropes 

• Captivity 

• Captivity - Kidnapping/Imprisonment 

• Doppelganger - Raped by Evil(er) Version of Crush/Lover 

• Face Slapping 

• Intimacy - Falsely Gentle Threatening Touches 

• Intimacy - Rapist Plays with Victim’s Hair 

• Love Interest Forced to Watch 

• Manhandling - Bodice Ripper Style Ravishment 

• Manhandling - Held Down 

• Obsession - Possessive Jealousy Leads to Rape 

• Position - Victim Bent Over Table/Desk 

• Resistance - Victim Fights Back 

• Scenario - Groping Escalates to Rape 

• Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time 

• Scenario - Rapist Taunts Victim's Loved Ones About Victim Being Raped 

• Whippings

I’ve only read the first book, but I was extremely intrigued by this villain who so closely resembled Claire’s lost love even as he was being incredibly cruel- but for better or for worse, it didn’t end up playing with that much. What if it had? What if Jack, already such a psychologically fucked-up man, found that his obsession with Jamie had now grown into an obsession with his wife as well? What if the way she acted so familiar towards him and yet also so afraid proved infuriatingly seductive? This can happen any time in the first book, in addition to or instead of what he does to Jamie, instead of or a continuation of his attack on her when she’s trying to reach the stones, etc. I don’t want him to just be going after her to upset or as a proxy for Jamie, but feel free to explore the psychological twistiness or all this. I just want to see this nasty man be nasty to our heroine!

The Lost Boys (Movies)

David noncons Star

Dwayne noncons Star

David and Dwayne noncon Star

David noncons Maria

Dwayne noncons Maria

David and Dwayne noncon Maria

• Arousal - Aroused Victim 

• Arousal - Horny Rapist 

• Attitude - Cheerful Rapist 

• Bad End - Kept as Sex Slaves 

• Captivity - Kidnapping/Imprisonment 

• Face Slapping 

• Intimacy - Forced Kissing 

• Manhandling - Held Down 

• Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty 

• Multiple Rapists - Ultimate Aggressor Holds/Toys With Victim As Others Rape Them 

• Punishment - Hunted with Rape as Penalty 

• Scenario - Forced to Live Out Darkest Fantasy 

• Mind Control - Victim Partially Resisting

David noncons Star

My very first vampire crush and the girl in his power! I’d love to see the lurid circumstances behind Star coming to live with David and his gang. It could have been something like what happened to Michael, where she was enticed into the cave and tricked into tricking David’s blood while the boys chanted her name, followed by sex she intitially agreed to which suddenly took a turn for the horrific when she realized she wasn’t going to be allowed to leave. She could have been outright kidnapped, a treat for the evening whom David decided he enjoyed enough to keep around. I love David’s mixture of seductive temptation and brash punk machismo, and I’d love to see him pushing around and taking possession of Star. The bad-trip cave scene after the blood drinking in the movie gives a great feeling of hallucinogenic eroticism, and I would love if you could capture some of that.

Dwayne noncons Star

Yeah, this one is because Dwayne is hot. So sue me. But I genuinely think there’s a lot of room to explore the secondary lost boys, and why not the quiet and mysterious one? What’s he thinking as he watches his leader toy with his beautiful prisoner? Maybe he’s jealous, and takes advantage of a time when David isn’t around, and Star would rather die than look to David for help, anyway. Maybe Star is kept as a group sex slave, and Dwayne is simply coming to take his turn (maybe he thinks that at least he’s not treating her as badly as some of the others, or maybe he’s the only one whose dark desires she’s really afraid of.) Or maybe she’s David’s girl, but he gives her to Dwayne one night as a reward- or as a punishment when Star was getting too defiant. Maybe he’s even the one who first found and lured her to the cave, before David asserted his leadership and took her for himself.

David and Dwayne noncon Star

…or maybe we can have it both ways! You could use the idea that Star belongs to the whole gang, or this could be something that more or less spontaneously happens as a result of a fight or a night of narcotic feeding gone out of control. Does Star prefer one to the other? Is the overwhelming sensation of both aggressors better or worse than just one? How do David and Dwayne interact here- as rivals, or as twisted friends? Is this something Star is used to, or something new and terrifying? Is it happening long into her captivity, or the very night she first learns she’s a captive?

David or Dwayne noncon Maria

My first ever fanfic involved Maria (I was so scared of writing an OC!) so I have a special place in my heart for her- and am thus requesting that bad stuff happens to her! The fact that we know so little about her means that you have a lot of freedom when it comes to making this whatever degree of noncon you want. Is she annoyed by regularly getting sexually harassed by the gang at work until that escalates to an outright attack, or does she enjoy flirting with them and go for a happy if risky bike ride with one of them? Everything I’ve said about the sexy confusion that might come from the blood wine holds true here- or are they trying to turn her at all? Is this an attack or recruitment? I love the opening with the boys prowling the boardwalk and creeping on girls, so let’s see what happens when that gets a little more intense!

Fear Street Trilogy (TV)

Nick Goode noncons Christine "Ziggy" Berman (Fear Street Trilogy)

• Aftermath - Victim Escapes After Rape 

• Arousal - Aroused Victim 

• Attitude - Gentle Rapist 

• Bondage 

• Intimacy - Forced Kissing 

• Intimacy - Victim Treated Like Lover 

• Obsession - I Love You Too Much To Ever Let You Go 

• Obsession - Rapist In Love With Victim 

• Obsession - Yandere 

• Resistance - Stoic Victim 

• Scenario - Gentle Rape 

• Wanted It but Not Like This - Rapist(s) Wanted It 

• Wanted It but Not Like This - Victim(s) Wanted It

My newest villain/heroine twisted ship! (I distinctly thought “Oh no, new bad ship!” while watching this.) I’m into this either in the camp era, the 1994 era, or anything in between. Nick is so into Ziggy that he’ll spare her, but not enough that he’ll stop being evil, and that’s wonderful! You could play with her not being sure of what is the truth, with him being so insistent and dragging her into darker and darker sexual acts until she doesn’t feel like she can say no and be heard- and why does such a nice boy keep saying such suspicious things? For a harder noncon scenario, she would have found out that he’s the killer, while he tries to assure her that it’s all worth it and they’ll be happy together, still reassuring her while he’s forcing himself on her. Happy or sad endings are both fine, as long as Ziggy survives.

Phantom of the Opera - Lloyd Webber

Erik makes Raoul de Chagny noncon Christine Daaé

• Bondage 

• Captivity 

• Inexperience - Victim In Over Their Head 

• Love Interest Unwillingly Enjoys Being Forced to Participate 

• Multiple Victims - Mutual Comfort 

• Obsession - Yandere 

• Punishment - For Being in a Consensual Relationship

I was very intrigued when I saw this prompt, and I would love to see more! I enjoy the sexual peril in the final lair scene, and maybe it could get even more intense. This could be purely a punishment for Christine and Raoul- give them what they think they want!- or you could have the Phantom also have issues around sex that makes him make Raoul a proxy. Or he could have offered Raoul or Christine the choice between him or her love.

Batman (Movies - Nolan)

Jonathan Crane noncons Original Female Character (Batman - Nolan)

• Begging 

• Bondage 

• Bondage - St. Andrew's Cross 

• Captivity 

• Intimacy - Falsely Gentle Threatening Touches 

• Obsession - Yandere 

• Praise - Condescending Praise 

• Punishment - Hunted with Rape as Penalty 

• Mind Control - Victim Partially Resisting 

• Substances - Victim is Drugged 

• Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time

Master of fear, master of torment- wouldn't he make a good villain for a noncon scenario? Crane could have picked a woman he cared about or simply a woman who caught his attention, and then it would be time for him to terrify her out of her mind. Maybe he's trying to change her mind and make her into his own personal Harley, maybe this is the only way he can connect to another human being, or maybe he's just being sadistic. I’ve nominated movie Crane, but feel free to bring in stuff from the comics!

Original M/F

Male pirates noncon women in a seaside town (Original M/F)

Pirate Captain noncons Aristocratic Prisoner (M/F)

Brooding Master of the House noncons Gothic Heroine (M/f)

Villain noncons Hero's Love Interest (m/f)

Wild West Outlaw noncons Female Hostage (m/f)

Mob Boss noncons Female Private Investigator (M/F)

Pirate Captain noncons Aristocratic Prisoner (M/F)

Crown Prince Brother noncons Bastard Princess Sister

Vampire noncons vampire hunter (M/F)

Victorian Slave Trader noncons Upper Class Woman He Is Selling (M/F)

• Aftermath - Victim Escapes After Rape 

• Arousal - Aroused Victim 

• Attitude - Cheerful Rapist 

• Bad End - Kept as Sex Slaves 

• Bad End - Kept in Harem 

• Bondage 

• Face Slapping 

• Intimacy - Forced Kissing 

• Love Interest Forced to Watch 

• Manhandling 

• Manhandling - Bodice Ripper Style Ravishment 

• Marriage - Rape to Force Marriage ('damaged goods law') 

• Motive - Rape Because Captor Thinks Captive is Pretty 

• Resistance - Defiant Victim 

• Slave auction

Victorian slaver noncons Victorian ladies

So all those Victorian scare stories about how if you go down the wrong alley you’ll get kidnapped and sold into slavery probably weren’t true...but what if they were? This can get into abductions, auctions, individual fates and buyers for the victims, possible rescues or full on bad ends.

Male pirates noncon women in seaside town

There are lots of movies I blame for this fantasy! Some of this can overlap with the slavery stuff above, but with a different time period and costumes, and the abduction is optional. The pirates here can be as rough or sophisticated as you like, and historical accuracy can be anything from Disney to Black Sails (love to Flint here…)

Pirate Captain noncons Aristocratic Prisoner

Similar to the above, but with a more old school bodice ripper flair! Is she being held for ransom, sale into slavery, or has the captain already chosen her for his bride? I’m not super hung up on historical accuracy here, but any fun details you want to add are welcome!

Brooding Master of the House noncons Gothic Heroine (M/f)

This can get dubcon-y, in the great tradition of dark Byronic antiheroes and old school bodice rippers, but it should still be terrifying for our poor heroine! A governess, a poor relation- you can come up with any backstory you want, so long as it puts her in his power. How dark and gothic and depraved can you get? I’d love to find out!

Villain noncons Hero's Love Interest (m/f)

What can I say, I enjoy this hackneyed trope! You have the freedom to choose the genre- superheroes, crime drama, spy thriller, epic fantasy, or whatever strikes your imagination. I’d rather this not be entirely about vengeance upon the hero- the villain should be attracted to the victim!- but that would obviously come into play. The hero might even be forced to watch. Good end or bad end are both fine!

Wild West Outlaw noncons Female Hostage (m/f)

All those Red Dead Redemption quests touched on something! What would a handsome lowlife do to a girl in his power? Is she frightened or defiant? Is he a lone gunslinger or part of a gang? I’m a fan of spaghetti westerns, so feel free to pile on all the tropes you like!

Mob Boss noncons Female Private Investigator (M/F)

I’m also a big fan of film noir, and I’d love to put a lady in danger who fits the cynical and world-weary yet righteous role. She’s been poking her nose where it doesn’t belong, and now she’s in a kind of trouble she’s never faced before. I would like to see her ultimately escape (and remain snarky throughout) but this will get rather nasty before it’s through.

Male Vampire noncons Female Vampire Hunter

I’m picturing something like an ahistorical gothic horror movie here (exploitation horror, I guess!) but you could also do a more modern urban fantasy erotica kind of thing. I like the thought of our warrior heroine overpowered but never stopping fighting, even at the hands of her very powerful and very sexy nemesis. It can end with him turning her or her staking him, as you wish.

I hope this has all been of some help, and I hope you have fun!